MAFS 2026 Drama: Claims That Scott McCristal Was “Still Married” During the Show

One of the biggest post-show controversies from Married at First Sight Australia 2026 involves groom Scott McCristal and allegations that he was still legally married to an American woman when he appeared on the show and married his on-screen bride Gia Fleur.

The claims surfaced in early 2026 and gained traction in April after a woman named Marisa McElory (also referred to as Marisa McCristal) publicly stated on social media that she and Scott are “still legally his wife.” Her sister added fuel by commenting that they remain “legally married in the States.”

who.com.au

newidea.com.au

Scott’s Background and the Allegations

Scott, a 33-year-old Gold Coast businessman involved in vehicle dealerships, finance, and other ventures, was matched with Gia Fleur. Their on-screen relationship was turbulent, marked by arguments (including over photos of an ex on his phone) and an eventual split at the reunion.

The marriage claims centre on a 2019 wedding in San Diego, California, to Marisa McElory, a personal trainer and former boxer. Photos from the ceremony (shared by a jewellery brand) show the couple looking happy at the altar. Marisa has alleged they are still legally married, while Scott maintains the marriage ended around three years ago (short-lived, reportedly under six months in some accounts).

Court documents indicate a divorce was granted in Australia on May 5, 2022. However, Marisa has stated she only recently received official confirmation of the finalization, which may explain the confusion—particularly regarding any U.S. aspects of the union. Additional unverified claims (including a restraining order) have circulated on social media but lack mainstream confirmation.

au.lifestyle.yahoo.com

graziadaily.co.uk

Scott and Gia’s On-Screen Journey

Scott and Gia initially connected strongly at their wedding and showed chemistry, but tensions escalated. Gia walked out at one point, and their relationship ended explosively. Post-show, both have moved on: Scott has confirmed he is in the early stages of a new romance, while Gia has gone public with a new boyfriend.

bristolpost.co.uk

newidea.com.au

Scott’s Reality TV History

Scott has appeared on several other Australian shows before MAFS 2026, including Blind Date (2018), Holey Moley (2021), and Million Dollar Island (2023). Fans “exposed” this history during the season, noting his prior TV appearances.

nowtolove.com.au

entertainmentdaily.com

Bottom Line

The “still married” claims are based on real public statements from Marisa McElory and her family, creating questions about the timing and cross-border finalization of the divorce. Scott insists he is divorced and has moved on. As with much MAFS fallout, the story involves differing personal accounts, social media drama, and the usual reality-TV editing gaps.

Channel 9 has not issued a detailed official response. Scott and Gia are no longer together, and both appear focused on life after the show.

These developments are typical of the intense scrutiny MAFS contestants face once the season airs. Always cross-check dramatic “shock” claims with multiple sources, as personal legal matters can be complex and evolve with paperwork.

Images above feature Scott McCristal from his MAFS 2026 appearances, his wedding with Gia Fleur, and related media coverage.