Fox didn’t just launch a show. It ignited a war.

On paper, Best Medicine is a monster success. The medical dramedy exploded out of the gate with 10.8 million viewers across platforms, including Hulu — marking Fox’s biggest debut in nearly three years. Executives are celebrating. Advertisers are thrilled. Headlines are glowing.

But online?

It’s chaos.

Because while the numbers scream hit, the audience reaction tells a very different story — one filled with anger, disbelief, and accusations of betrayal.

For longtime fans of the British original Doc Martin, this isn’t a remake. It’s an offense.

Social media lit up within hours of the premiere. Viewers weren’t debating plot points or performances — they were questioning why the show exists at all. Words like “disgraceful,” “embarrassing,” and “soulless” began trending alongside the title. Some fans didn’t even finish the episode before posting furious reactions.

“This misses the entire point of Doc Martin,” one viewer wrote.
“They took something sharp and human and turned it into network fluff,” said another.
“Just because you can remake it doesn’t mean you should,” echoed hundreds more.

What’s fueling the backlash isn’t just nostalgia — it’s tone. The original series thrived on restraint, awkwardness, and emotional discomfort. Critics of Best Medicine argue the Fox version sands down those edges, replacing subtle character tension with broader jokes and a shinier, safer formula designed to please everyone… and satisfy no one.

Ironically, critics themselves are split — but far gentler. Reviews praise the cast’s commitment and the show’s accessibility, calling it “competent,” “watchable,” and “polished.” Compliments that, to furious fans, sound like insults.

Because this isn’t about competence.
It’s about soul.

And that’s where the divide becomes brutal.

The show’s massive debut proves curiosity was sky-high. People tuned in expecting magic — or at least respect for what came before. Instead, many walked away feeling like something intimate had been repackaged, diluted, and sold back to them with a smile.

Now the question hanging over Best Medicine isn’t whether it’s a hit.

It’s whether those millions will come back.

Because record-breaking premieres don’t guarantee longevity — especially when the loudest voices aren’t just disappointed… they’re offended.

This could still become Fox’s next long-running success.
Or it could go down as a textbook case of how big numbers can’t save a remake that loses the trust of its audience.

One thing is certain:
Best Medicine didn’t just debut.

It detonated.